Home » Frightfest 2017 Review: Replace

Frightfest 2017 Review: Replace

Barbara Crampton

The two big selling points of this German-Canadian co-production are Queen Barbara Crampton and the promise of some totally disgusting body horror (though the great Richard Stanley has a writing credit, for those of that persuasion). Replace doesn’t fall down on either but it’s still not an entirely successful enterprise, particularly in this sub-genre.

Rebecca Forsythe is Kira, a young woman who turns to Crampton’s sinister doc when her skin starts to, well, rot. When we first meet her, Kira is accompanying a young man home to his apartment after a night out. Then, upon waking up the next morning, Kira finds him gone while everything in the place appears to be in her name.

It’s a strange setup for a body horror movie that isn’t entirely necessary here. The deterioration of Kira’s body, shown in unwavering, graphic, gross-out detail via some pretty gnarly makeup and prosthetics, is enough on its own without the addition of her mental breakdown. Likewise, a sub-plot sort-of romance complicates matters without adding anything of value.

Rebecca Forsythe in Replace

As a lead, Forsythe is fine. She looks distractingly like Chloe Grace Moretz mixed with Elizabeth Olsen, though lacks the charisma or fire of either. Her performance seems permanently pitched at “girl in peril” though Kira’s morality rightfully comes into question following the movie’s big reveal (it’s not really a twist, more of a confirmation of what’s been obvious from the outset).

Crampton has good fun playing the doctor, for once, as a combination mad scientist and disappointed mother but there isn’t nearly enough of her. Both she and Kira are complex, nuanced, layered female characters, the kind we’ve been screaming to see in movies for years, but where Crampton is more than up to the challenge, Forsythe flails.

The body horror stuff is satisfyingly gross, at least, and offered up to us right off the bat with a yucky, peeling little finger. The question of whether Kira is ageing rapidly, or if she’s rotting from the inside out, fades into the background once she’s been driven to steal the best-moisturised skin of her fellow living,  breathing humans (because corpse skin is no good, you see).

Rebecca Forsythe and Barbara Crampton in ReplaceReplace has a similar sleek and shine to The Neon Demon, though without that film’s surrealist elements. It’s also overlong at an hour and forty minutes, with a saggy middle that fails to move the plot along whatsoever, and the denouement is nonsensical, not to mention unsatisfying given how long it’s taken to get there.

The romantic subplot goes nowhere and is a bit Mulholland Dr.-ish, but there is some stuff to enjoy here, from the movie’s dark sense of humour to the score’s thumping, new rave goodness and the wonderfully gory body horror. It’s worth a watch to see Crampton intone “And all…for vanity” in that wonderful cadence of hers. If only she were the focus throughout.

Director(s): Norbert Keil
Writer(s): Norbert Keil, Richard Stanley, Scarlett Amaris, Bernd Stack

Stars: Barbara Crampton, Rebecca Forsythe, Lucie Aron, Sean Knopp
Release: TBC
Studio/ Production Co: Sparkling Pictures
Language: English
Length: 101 minutes
Sub-Genre: Body horror

Liked it? Take a second to support Joey Keogh on Patreon!
Share This Post
Written by Joey Keogh
Slasher fanatic Joey Keogh has been writing since she could hold a pen, and watching horror movies even longer. Aside from making a little home for herself at Wicked Horror, Joey also writes for Birth.Movies.Death, The List, and Vague Visages among others. Her actual home boasts Halloween decorations all year round. Hello to Jason Isaacs.
Have your say!